Science & technology | Naval mines

Mines are the neglected workhorses of naval strategy

They are cheap to deploy and expensive to get rid of

HFBA5W 140516-N-QY759-085 BALTIC SEA (May 16, 2014) A Canadian explosive ordnance disposal team detonates a World War II German naval mine after safely removing it from the wreck of a German minelayer worked by them and U.S. Navy Explosive Ordnance Disposal Mobile Unit (EODMU) 8. EODMU-8 is participating in Open Spirit, a multinational operation that disposes of mines and other ordnance remaining on the seabed from World War I and World War II to reduce the risk to navigation, fishing and to the environment in the Baltic Sea. (U.S. Navy photo by Mass Communication 1st Class David R. Krigbaum/Released

The sexy end of modern naval forces, observes Duncan Potts, a retired vice-admiral in Britain’s Royal Navy, is stuff like guided-missile destroyers, fast jets and nuclear submarines. But it is often a far humbler device, the naval mine, that does much of the damage. During the second world war, these static underwater bombs are reckoned to have sunk 2,100 vessels. Not as many as the 4,600 accounted for by submarines, but far more than attacks by aircraft or artillery bombardment by other ships. Subsequent conflicts have seen mines cripple or send to the bottom nearly four times as many American warships as all other types of weapons combined.

This article appeared in the Science & technology section of the print edition under the headline “Lurkers below”

The disunited states of America

From the September 3rd 2022 edition

Discover stories from this section and more in the list of contents

Explore the edition

Discover more

Elon Musk’s SpaceX has achieved something extraordinary

If SpaceX can land and reuse the most powerful rocket ever made what can’t it do?

Surface of Jupiter's icy moon Europa.

Could life exist on one of Jupiter’s moons?

A spacecraft heading to Europa is designed to find out


Ships wake in the ocean with swell & stormy skies.

Noise-dampening tech could make ships less disruptive to marine life

Solutions include bendy propellers and “acoustic black holes”


Meet Japan’s hitchhiking fish

Medaka catch rides on obliging birds, confirming one of Darwin’s hunches

AI wins big at the Nobels

Awards went to the discoverers of micro-RNA, pioneers of artificial-intelligence models and those using them for protein-structure prediction

Google’s DeepMind researchers among recipients of Nobel prize for chemistry

The award honours protein design and the use of AI for protein-structure prediction